Tuesday, October 14, 2014

Human Variation and Race

1. Select only ONE of the following environmental stresses: (a) heat, (b) high levels of solar radiation, (c) cold, or (d) high altitude. Discuss specifically how this environmental stress negatively impacts the survival of humans by disturbing homeostasis. (5 pts) In looking at Human variation, it is hard to see beyond the color. As humans we have developed on way thinking when it comes to race. We have created stereotypes that are judgmental and actually have no scientific reasoning behind them. This leads to assumptions about people in regards to race that are just illogical. There are many different environmental stresses that can affect race of a region or person. Specifically, let’s look at heat and how it negatively impacts the survival of humans by disturbing homeostasis. Increased heat can be very detrimental to humans and eventually lead to death. When body temperature rises to 105 degrees or more it is considered hyperthermia. Hyperthermia can result in deterioration of internal organs and eventually death.

2. Identify 4 ways in which humans have adapted to this stress, choosing one specific adaptation from each of the different types of adaptations listed above (short term, facultative, developmental and cultural). Include images of the adaptations. (5 pts each/ 20 pts total) Four ways in which humans adapt to stress can be categorized into short term, facultative, developmental, and cultural. First a short term way humans react to heat is by sweating. Our bodies use sweating as a way to cool down our core temperature to maintain homeostasis. If it weren’t for sweating, our bodies would over heat very rapidly to the point of no return. Secondly, a facultative adaption to heat is skin pigment darkening, or tanning. When an environment experiences extreme heat, this also means there is an excess of ultraviolet light, which can cause skin pigment to darken. Thirdly, a developmental adaption to heat is body size. Groups that live in areas that have high heat are often very tall and slender. This is because the more surface area your body has, the more heat it releases. This also leads to individuals having longer arms and legs. Finally a cultural adaptation to heat is seen in the clothing. Clothing worn by different cultures in high heat environments are typically more revealing. This is because the more clothes you wear, generates more heat. Therefore in high heat environments, the less clothes the more heat your body will release into the environment, and keep you cool.

3. What are the benefits of studying human variation from this perspective across environmental clines? Can information from explorations like this be useful to help us in any way? Offer one example of how this information can be used in a productive way. (5 pts) The benefits of exploring human variation from the environmental influences perspective are numerous. It allows us to be subjective when looking at our differences. Although humans are a species with very small genetic variations, we tend to put a lot of stress on our variations. This causes us to have stereotypes and subjective reasoning.


4. How would you use race to understand the variation of the adaptations you listed in #2? Explain why the study of environmental influences on adaptations is a better way to understand human variation than by the use of race. (10 pts) Again, by looking at the different adaptions to heat it helps us to realize that everything happens for a reason. Skin pigment is a result of environment and that’s it. The traits that make up a culture are different because of environmental pressures and adaptations. Yes, they are different but they all derive from a survival adaptation. Without our differences, we would not be able to habitat most of the environment’s on this planet. So, all in all our differences is what makes us a strong and durable species… so far.

5 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Amanda,

    I enjoyed reading your post on how heat affects our bodies. In addition to sweating, our bodies adapt to the heat through vasodilation. The blood vessels cause flushing of the skin because more blood is close to the surface and this blood moves the heat from the body core to the surface where it can be dissipated easily by radiation.

    Also, in the United States, more people die from heat than cold and this is mainly due to babies being left in locked cars on hot days.

    Susan

    ReplyDelete
  3. This was a refresher post for me because I almost forgot about hyperthermia and I'm thankful for reading this. When I think about how our body reacts to certain predicaments I'm always amazed especially when it comes to heat and cold.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great opening discussion!

    Missing images?

    Good short term adaptation.

    Tanning is actually an adaptation to solar radiation, not to heat. An example of a facultative adaptation to heat stress is vasodilation, which opens capillaries closer to the skin to help dissipate heat.

    Good discussion on the developmental adaptation. Make sure you are familiar with Bergmann and Allen's rules which help to explain this.

    Western culture does indeed tend to adopt a practice of less clothing to manage heat stress. Is that a general rule across all cultures?

    I agree that there are social reasons why using the adaptive approach is beneficial, but are there any other more applied benefits? How can we use the information on body shape to help society in general? Do you think this information, given it's genetic information, might be helpful in the medical field when caring for patients of different genetic origins when considering issues of weight? Should all patients be treated the same when it comes to what might be considered a "healthy" weight?

    "Skin pigment is a result of environment and that’s it."

    You never mention the word "race" in this discussion, so I'm having some difficulty seeing where your opinion lies on that topic, but the quote above seems to suggest you fall into the "race has nothing to do with explaining our physical characteristics" camp? Some clarification on this would be helpful.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Shoot! Thanks for clarifying vasodilation and yes, I didn't realize we needed pictures also. Bummed that I missed out on such easy points... Duh!

      In response to your questions about body size in relation to excessive heat, now that I think about it, not all cultures reduce clothing to help deal with heat. Actually, I think some Arab countries actually wear more clothing to combat the suns affects. However, this could be more to shield from excessive UV exposure, but I am not sure. I definitely think it would be beneficial for us to re-think what a healthy weight is depending on the environment. Specifically with Western Cultures, I think it would help with body and self esteem issues that people struggle with everyday.

      Anyway, yes based off the information in this chapter, I believe that race was evolved out of environmental reasons and has no relation to the stereotypes and characteristics that are often associated with it.

      Delete